Benat was introduced off the bench in the 68th minute and nearly scored with his first touch, but his long-distance shot on goal was batted away by Wanderers custodian Daniel Margush.
Fringe Socceroos goalkeeper Adam Federici was busy all night at the other end, keeping the Bulls in the contest with a string of fantastic saves – the last one coming in injury time to foil Kwame Yeboah.
But the win was thoroughly deserved for Macarthur, whose positive attacking football and intriguing mix of experienced campaigners like Benat, and young stars like Hollman and Lachlan Rose already feels like the breath of fresh air the A-League desperately needed.
Rose thought he’d scored the club’s historic first goal in the 51st minute, when he tapped in a cutback from James Meredith, but only realised he’d been ruled offside after he started celebrating.
There was no shame in the defeat for Western Sydney in their first match under coach Carl Robinson, who would be rightly pleased with how quickly his remodelled team has gelled, albeit with no end product to show for it. There was also clear improvement needed from strike duo Simon Cox and Bernie Ibini.
A tension in the air – typical of a derby – was palpable from the outset, but Ziggy Gordon may not remember it well: his first minute in Wanderers colours ended with a ball straight to the head, courtesy of Loic Puyo’s thump on goal from metres away.
Ten minutes later came the controversy. Prized Western Sydney recruit Graham Dorrans unleashed a shot from well outside the box that caught Aleksandar Jovanovic in the stomach. Referee Kurt Ams whistled straight away for a handball penalty, but he rightly revised his decision after visiting the VAR screen on the sideline.
From then on, Macarthur had the ascendancy. Their most promising attacking outlet proved to be Moudi Najjar, the Young Socceroos striker on loan to the Bulls this season from Melbourne City.
Playing on the left wing, Najjar often drifted inside and found numerous opportunities lurking in the space opened up by Matt Derbyshire’s intelligent movement.
Najjar got his head onto tasty crosses from Ivan Franjic and Denis Genreau but couldn’t hit the target with either, and had his best chance four minutes from the break, when he was picked out again by Rose, only to nod the ball fractionally wide of the right post.
The Wanderers responded with their best stretch of attacking football to that point, with a flurry of shots that tested Federici’s reflexes – all coming in the shadows of the first half.
Ibini had the last sight on goal for the first half, taking a swipe at a loose ball that fell his way which whizzed past the wrong side of the upright, before Federici was again forced to deny efforts from James Troisi and Keanu Baccus on the other side of the break.
Vince is a sports reporter for The Sydney Morning Herald.